Kindness Is Not The Solution

Kindness Is Not The Solution

Train Your Brain To Sustain It Under Strain

Australia has had too many rehearsals for catastrophe.

Fire seasons that turn the sky orange.

Floods that make cities impossible to navigate. Towns cut off. People exhausted. Systems stretched.

And Australia is not unique. Across the world, earthquakes, hurricanes, wars, pandemics and disasters trigger the same pattern.

When the stakes are real, humans remember each other.

Neighbours drag hoses across fences. Strangers cook for strangers. Someone with a ute becomes logistics. Someone with a spare room becomes shelter.

Then the water recedes.
The smoke clears.
The news cycle moves on.

And we lose it.

Not completely, but enough to feel the drop. Enough to notice that everyday life makes us narrower, busier, more transactional.

Like kindness was a temporary upgrade we install during emergencies and uninstall when “normal” returns.

So here’s the real question.

If we can be this human under extreme pressure, why do we struggle to stay human under ordinary stress?

Stress Changes The Brain

That’s not an excuse. It’s a fact.

Under strain, your brain shifts into protection mode. When the stress system surges, the prefrontal cortex can lose its grip fast.

That’s the part of the brain that supports perspective, self-control and wise restraint. Under stress, more reactive systems get louder and faster (Arnsten, 2009).

Translation: when strain rises, you become more likely to choose speed over empathy, certainty over curiosity, task over relationship.

Not because you became a bad person.

Because your brain is doing what it evolved to do.

The modern problem is that our “tigers” are invisible and constant.

Deadlines.
Notifications.
Money pressure.
Social comparison.
Performance metrics.

Chronic stress keeps the threat system humming. Over time, you can become competent and inconsiderate at the same time.

Why Kindness Shows Up In Disasters

In an emergency, the threat is shared and clear. The goal is obvious. The “me” story shrinks and the “we” story takes the wheel.

Kindness stops being a trait and becomes a survival technology.

Then normal life returns and the threat becomes private again.

Pressure turns into background noise.

Status games restart. People protect their time, their image, their advantage. Relationships quietly become transactions.

That’s what happens when the brain narrows and identity collapses back to “me.”

The Weird Mirror Of Our Century

We are building machines that learn.

Scientists have even shown that neurons grown in a lab can learn from feedback in a simulated game environment (Kagan et al., 2022).

Meanwhile, many fully grown humans struggle with the simplest kind of learning: staying decent when stressed.

That’s the mirror. We are engineering intelligence and forgetting that character is a skill.

Kindness Is Not The Solution

Kindness is the output of a regulated brain.

Kindness is your ability to keep the prefrontal cortex online when your threat system is shouting. It is the capacity to respond from values instead of adrenaline (Arnsten, 2009).

The brain can sustain kindness under pressure, but not by accident.

It happens when you train it.

In the i4 Neuroleader™ Model language, this is the difference between being driven by threat and reward loops versus leading from regulation, values and contribution.

Three Ways To Train Kindness Under Strain

1) Regulate first. Respond second.

Before you speak, send the email, make the call, correct the person, pause for ten seconds and downshift your physiology.

Slow the breath.
Relax the jaw.
Stretch your spine.

This is what gives you access to nuance again. The ability to hold more than one truth at once.

2) Upgrade “nice” into “true and kind” and ban contempt like toxic waste

Niceness avoids friction. Kindness can include a boundary, a hard conversation, a clear no.

Jefferson Fisher puts it plainly: being “nice” gets people steamrolled in difficult conversations and respectful firmness is the real move (Fisher, 2025).

Now add the contempt layer.

Gottman and Levenson’s work shows contempt is not a cute personality quirk. It is corrosive and predictive of relational breakdown patterns over time (Gottman & Levenson, 1992).

Here’s the leap that matters: contempt is not just a couple's problem.

Contempt is what happens when you decide another human is beneath you.

Superiority.
Mockery.
Eye rolls.
Sarcasm with a knife inside it.

Once contempt enters any relationship, trust starts dying quietly.

If kindness is honesty without humiliation, contempt is the opposite: truth used to punish, dominate or dismiss.

So make this a personal standard in every relationship you’re in, not only romantic ones:

Be direct. Be clear. Be firm.

Do not add contempt.

Do not make people small to make yourself feel big.

3) Treat the relationship as part of the task

Under pressure, people sacrifice trust to buy speed. It feels efficient until everything fractures.

Trust is not decoration.
Trust is infrastructure.

Without it, performance becomes brittle.

What Really Matters When Normal Returns

Australia’s disasters prove something important.

Kindness is not rare.
It is situational.

So the work is not to wait for a crisis to bring out your best self.

The work is to train your brain, so your best self shows up on an ordinary Tuesday.

Because the world is not saved by one big moment of kindness.

It is built by people who can sustain it when things get tense and who refuse to let contempt be the price of productivity.



Join us!

Subscribe to receive notifications on new articles!

Get our neuroscience & leadership insights.

• Arnsten, A. F. T. (2009). Stress signalling pathways that impair prefrontal cortex structure and function.

• Fisher, J. (2025, October 7). Being nice won’t save you in difficult conversations [Podcast episode]. The Jefferson Fisher Podcast.

• Gottman, J. M., & Levenson, R. W. (1992). Marital processes predictive of later dissolution: Behaviour, physiology and health.

• Kagan, B. J., Kitchen, A. C., Tran, N. T., Habibollahi, F., Khajehnejad, M., Parker, B. J., Bhat, A., Rollo, B., Razi, A., & Friston, K. J. (2022). In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world.

About the Author

Silvia Damiano author photo test

Silvia Damiano

Founder & CEO - About my Brain Institute

Award-winning leadership expert, scientist, educator, author, filmmaker, speaker, coach and creator of the i4 Neuroleader™ Model & Methodology.

Silvia Damiano’s scientific background and deep curiosity about the human brain led her into years of research exploring how people actually think, decide and act, not in theory, but in the moments where it counts.

Silvia's work sits at the intersection of neuroscience and human behaviour, focused on what happens under pressure, in relationships and through change. Over time, this evolved into a clear direction, helping people understand themselves with enough precision to lead, adapt and move forward with intention.

More Articles

Kindness Is Not The Solution
Discover why kindness isn't the ultimate solution and learn how to train your brain to sustain empathy and decency even under everyday stress and pressure.
How Much Social Connection Do Humans Really Need?
Your brain reads rejection like pain. Discover the minimum social connection you need to stay well plus why meaning beats numbers and culture matters.
The Neuroscience Of Idleness: Why Dilly-Dallying Is The New Mindfulness
Discover the neuroscience behind idleness and why taking time to dilly-dally can enhance creativity, self-awareness and overall well-being.