Influence

From Defensive To Reflective

Competency: Agility
Attribute: Thoughtful
heart-2-heart-conversation-prompt-cards-i4-neuroleader-assessment-deck-113

        
    Introduction

    Benefits of Shifting from Defensive to Reflective

    Receiving feedback can be challenging, especially when it touches on something as personal as being called inconsiderate. For many, the natural response is to become defensive, feeling hurt or misunderstood. However, while defensiveness is a common reaction, it doesn’t lead to personal growth. Shifting from a defensive mindset to a reflective one can help you process the feedback in a healthy, productive way. This article explores how to manage emotional reactions, understand the root of the feedback, and turn it into an opportunity for self-improvement.

    • Personal Growth:
      By reflecting on feedback instead of reacting defensively, you open the door to self-awareness and growth, allowing you to make meaningful changes.

    • Improved Relationships:
      Taking time to understand and respond thoughtfully to feedback helps build trust and strengthen relationships.

    • Emotional Resilience:
      Learning to manage your emotions in the face of criticism builds resilience, enabling you to handle future feedback more gracefully.

    Newsletter

            
    Self-Paced Coaching Questions

    Gauging How You Respond

    Consider these questions:

    • How do I usually react when someone gives me feedback that feels personal or negative?
    • Have there been times when defensiveness has caused further conflict or misunderstanding in my relationships?
    • What can I learn about myself from the feedback I receive, even when it feels uncomfortable?

    Newsletter

             
    Strategies

    Shift from Defensive to Reflective

    • Pause and Acknowledge Your Emotions:
      When receiving feedback that feels personal, your first instinct might be to defend yourself or push back. Instead, pause and acknowledge your emotional response. It’s okay to feel hurt, frustrated or misunderstood. Take a moment to breathe and process these feelings before responding. This pause helps you avoid reacting impulsively and gives you time to approach the situation with a clearer mind.

    • Seek Clarity with an Open Mind:
      Often, feedback that feels personal is unclear or delivered in a way that doesn’t sit well with you. Rather than assuming the worst, approach the situation with curiosity. Ask questions to clarify the feedback without sounding defensive. For instance, instead of saying, “I don’t see how I was inconsiderate,” try, “Could you help me understand how my actions affected you?”

    • Reframe Feedback as an Opportunity for Growth:
      Once you’ve processed your emotions and sought clarity, shift your focus to how the feedback can serve you in your personal development. Even if you don’t agree with everything said, there’s often a kernel of truth or a valuable perspective that can help you improve. Reframing feedback as a tool for growth allows you to look at it objectively, without feeling personally attacked.

    Shifting from a defensive response to reflective thinking when faced with personal feedback can be transformative. While it’s natural to feel defensive when called inconsiderate or criticized in other ways, approaching feedback with a reflective mindset fosters better relationships, strengthens emotional resilience and promotes continuous self-development. The next time you receive feedback that feels personal, remember that reflection, not reaction, leads to growth.

    From our Blog

    Influence Articles

    Check out the latest blogs to learn more about this topic!

    Respect Is A Cornerstone Of Leadership
    Respect-Is-A-Cornerstone-Of-Leadership - About my Brain Institute

    Respect Is A Cornerstone Of Leadership

    26 March 2020 3 min read
    4 Methods to Increase Your Influence with Others
    4-Methods-to-Increase-Your-Influence-with-Others- About my Brain Institute

    4 Methods to Increase Your Influence with Others

    2 May 2019 2 min read
    Giving The Gift Of Time To Increase Your Influence
    Giving-the-Gift-of-Time-to-Increase-Your-Influence - About my Brain Institute

    Giving The Gift Of Time To Increase Your Influence

    24 January 2019 4 min read

    Bibliography

    This article has been inspired by the following sources: 

    • Kabat-Zinn, J. (1994). Wherever you go, there you are: Mindfulness meditation in everyday life. Hyperion.
    • Cuddy, A. (2015). Presence: Bringing your boldest self to your biggest challenges. Little, Brown and Company.
    • Grant, A. (2013). Give and take: Why helping others drives our success. Viking.
    • Tannen, D. (1990). You just don’t understand: Women and men in conversation. Ballantine Books.
    • Rosenberg, M. B. (2003). Nonviolent communication: A language of life. PuddleDancer Press.
    • Siegel, D. J. (2010). The mindful therapist: A clinician’s guide to mindsight and neural integration. W. W. Norton & Company.